Money or Integrity: A Designer’s Dilemma

Recently, I faced a challenging decision that made me reflect deeply on the balance between money and integrity. I was approached with a project that offered a substantial paycheck, but it came with a significant catch: the design was, to put it mildly, an aesthetic nightmare.

The task was to recreate a book published ten years ago. The client had designed it themselves and was incredibly proud of it. Unfortunately, the design was a glaring example of poor aesthetics. Imagine a layout so jarring that it made your eyes bleed – that’s the best way I can describe it. Despite my professional opinion and the manager’s agreement that the design was fundamentally flawed, the client was adamant about preserving the original look.

I tried to diplomatically explain what was wrong with the design and why it was a disservice to the book’s content. However, the client remained firm in their decision. Fortunately, they postponed the project, so I didn’t have to officially turn it down.

This situation left me considering a crucial question: should I take on such projects and keep my involvement discreet, or should I decline and keep my conscience clear?

On one hand, accepting the project would mean a significant financial reward. In a field where freelance work can be unpredictable, turning down well-paying jobs isn’t an easy choice. I could silently take the money and let the client be happy with their dated design. After all, beauty is in the eye of the beholder, right?

On the other hand, integrity is at the core of my professional values. As a designer, my reputation is built on the quality and effectiveness of my work. Agreeing to a project that contradicts my principles could tarnish that reputation. More importantly, it could compromise my sense of professional pride and satisfaction.

What would you do in such a situation? Would you take the money, keep your involvement under wraps, or stand by your principles and decline the project?

This dilemma reminds me of the constant balancing act between financial needs and professional integrity. Every designer must confront this decision at some point.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Ask me anything

Not sure where to start and need some consulting service? Have questions about my work?

Or you do know what you need and want to work together on a project? Maybe you just want to send me a friendly hello?

Fell free to reach out to me.